Proving Earned Wages
Identify the promise, earning conditions, retained discretion, and records establishing unpaid compensation.
Earned Wage or Discretionary Gratuity?
Under New York law, evaluate whether the bonus is compensation for the employee’s own services, whether payment was guaranteed or discretionary, and whether the employee satisfied the conditions for earning it. Individual performance metrics, specific hiring or retention promises, contractual minimums, and payment history can establish an enforceable compensation obligation.
Identify what discretion the employer actually retained: whether to award a bonus, how to calculate it, or when to pay it. A contractual right to participate in a pool does not by itself establish an individual allocation or statutory wage status.
A provision forfeiting an already-earned, nondiscretionary wage bonus may be unenforceable. In William Mattar, P.C. v Riley, the court rejected forfeiture of compensation tied to work and results the employee had already produced. Continued-employment conditions require separate analysis where compensation remains discretionary or contingent.
Labor Law § 193(5) expressly covers unauthorized failure to pay wages. Neu v Amelia US LLC sustained a nonpayment claim alongside breach of contract. Older decisions distinguishing wholesale withholding from deductions must be read in light of the 2021 amendment and its nonretroactivity.
Hallmarks of an Earned Bonus
Individual Output: Identify the employee’s work or results to which the promised payment relates, including generated fees, completed transactions, or agreed service periods.
Defined Conditions: Identify the earning conditions, when they were satisfied, and any discretion or contingency that remained.
Specific Inducement: Preserve promises made to induce the employee to join, remain, relocate, or perform particular work.
Payment History: Compare prior calculations, payments, and communications with the governing agreement. A consistent formula may support the asserted obligation; the effect depends on the express terms and facts.
Equity Compensation and Contractual Rights
For equity awards, analyze the contractual entitlement separately from statutory wage status. Review the grant, plan, vesting schedule, repurchase terms, amendments, board approvals, and governing law.
Market-dependent or discretionary incentive compensation may fall outside New York’s statutory wage definition even where enforceable contractual rights exist. Mandatory pool language does not automatically establish a personal allocation. In Kasselakis v Tiptree, Inc., the court recognized mandatory language but nevertheless dismissed the cash-bonus, Class B-1 unit, and related wage claims under the agreements before it.
Questions That Define the Claim
The Promise: What payment or equity allocation was promised to this employee?
The Conditions: What work, service period, approval, or other event was required?
The Discretion: What decisions remained open, and had the employer already made them?
The Timing: When was the compensation earned, vested, due, and withheld?
The Remedy: Do the facts support breach of contract, a statutory wage claim, or both? Termination labels do not resolve these questions.
The Evidence to Preserve
Internal Admissions: Preserve communications describing compensation as earned, approved, allocated, or payable. These can directly undermine a later discretion defense when tied to the governing terms.
Performance Records: Preserve spreadsheets, dashboards, transaction records, and calculations showing satisfaction of agreed earning conditions.
Guaranteed Minimums: Preserve offer letters, compensation amendments, and hiring or retention promises establishing a payment floor.
Process Evidence: Identify who determined the award, what approvals occurred, and when the amount became fixed. Preserve records lawfully and identify witnesses who can explain them.
Authorities
Ryan v Kellogg Partners Institutional Services, 19 NY3d 1 (2012).
William Mattar, P.C. v Riley, 2024 NY Slip Op 51867(U).
Neu v Amelia US LLC, 2024 NY Slip Op 02019.
Request a Severance Review